‘Suffered enough’: Calls grow to save distressed bear in Pakistani zoo

By Aamir Latif

KARACHI, Pakistan (AA) – Wildlife activists and experts have sounded the alarm over the life of Rano, a lone female Himalayan bear crammed in a small cage at a zoo in Pakistan’s commercial capital Karachi.

The calls come on the heels of the death of a female African elephant in April this year due to “inappropriate” conditions at the same facility, prompting local and international organizations to push for immediate steps to save other animals from a similar fate.

Also known as the Himalayan red bear, the Himalayan brown bear is a subspecies of the brown bear found in the western Himalayas. It is the largest mammal in the region, with males reaching up to 2.2 meters (7.2 feet) in length, while females are a little smaller.

The bear, whose natural habitat is the cold alpine meadows of Deosai National Park and other mountain regions of northern Pakistan, is a critically endangered species with only 150 to 200 left in the country, mainly because of human intrusion and the ravages of climate change.

Languishing in a barren cage, Rano was brought to the Karachi zoo in 2017 along with an Asiatic black bear who died in 2020.

Her cage has two small chambers and an open courtyard with a tiny pond in the middle. The weather-beaten bear’s coat has already started losing its color due to the hot and humid weather of the port city.

In the wild, she would spend her days foraging for flowers, fruits, berries, grasses, insects and small mammals such as the marmot.

Today, she paces back and forth in a corner of her cage as a small crowd huddles around for a better look.

“She needs to be taken out of Karachi zoo as soon as possible because she does not belong in a zoo,” Mahera Omar, a wildlife activist from Karachi, told Anadolu.

“If she’s not shifted, Rano may meet a fate similar to the African elephant who died an agonizing death earlier this year,” she said.

Omar insisted that the bear should be moved to a wildlife sanctuary in northeastern Pakistan before this winter.

Located in Chakwal, a district in Punjab province, Balkasar Bioresource Research Centre provides a rehabilitation home and veterinary care for rescued bears.

The sanctuary, established by a wildlife biologist Fakhar-i-Abbas in 2010, has already agreed to take in Rano.

“Rano cannot wait. The ethical thing to do would be to let her go, and let her go now, to the sanctuary. She has suffered enough,” said Omar, co-founder of the Pakistan Animal Welfare Society.

Endorsing her argument, Sarwar Jamali, a veteran wildlife expert, said Rano will continue to suffer and face more health risks if she is not shifted to a sanctuary at the earliest.

- Controversy over origin

Rano is believed to have been poached from the wild as a cub and spent years in captivity in a private zoo before being brought to her current home in 2017 along with a male Asiatic black bear.

The pair was made to live inside a Victorian-era cement pit that housed the zoo’s previous bear, Emma, who died in 2013.

Following the death of the black bear, it took a court order for authorities to shift Rano to her current cage.

However, Aamir Ismail Rizvi, deputy director of Karachi zoo, claims that Rano is a Syrian bear and was brought to the facility “under an exchange program from a private zoo” operating in the northern outskirts of Karachi.

“It is a Syrian brown bear that does not require cold conditions. It’s very much fine here,” he told Anadolu.

“She will be killed by other animals if we release her in the wild because she does not have the skills to survive out there, mainly hunting skills.”

Jamali, who served for 33 years in the wildlife department, echoed the view, but emphasized that Rano should be moved to a sanctuary.

“Animals like Rano who have lived with or near humans cannot be sent to their natural habitats as it will be fatally dangerous for them,” he told Anadolu.

He said the bear should be sent to the Balkasar sanctuary where the weather is much more suitable than Karachi.

After rehabilitation, he added, she could be moved back to her natural habitat in Deosai.

However, a zoo official who spoke to Anadolu on condition of anonymity as he was not allowed to go on record, dismissed Rizvi’s claim regarding Rano’s origins.

“She is from the Himalayas, 100%,” he insisted.

He said the chances of Rano getting used to Karachi’s hot and humid weather are slim at best.

Loneliness is aggravating her suffering, he said, explaining that being all alone “gradually affects the mental behavior of wild animals … that are used to living in groups.”

“This is what’s called zoochosis, and it’s common in captive wildlife; repetitive stereotypic behaviors such as head bobbing, swaying and pacing,” according to Omar.

“She’s bored. She’s stressed. She’s constantly exposed to noise from loudspeakers and visitors. She has absolutely nothing to do inside the cage,” she added.

- ‘Zoos are dark relics of the past’

Javed Mahar, a senior wildlife official in the southern Sindh province, told Anadolu that the department has recommended that Rano should be immediately shifted to the sanctuary.

“But the zoo management is insisting on keeping her here, which is not at all a suitable place for the poor animal,” he said.

Established in 1870 and officially named the Karachi Zoological Gardens, the facility is home to hundreds of wild animals, birds and reptiles that continue to attract a large number of visitors, particularly children.

For quite some time, the 152-year-old zoo has been known for its neglect of animals, with repeated calls for it to be shut down permanently.

It was in the headlines earlier this month following the death of Noor Jehan, a 17-year-old elephant that suffered agony due to months of inadequate care and treatment.

She was operated on by foreign veterinarians but could not survive.

She was one of the last four captive elephants in Pakistan, all of them in Karachi.

Last year, an Austrian veterinarian team was called in to operate on Madhubala, an 18-year-old elephant, after she had a severe infection because of a broken tusk.

Experts have suggested moving Madhubala from Karachi zoo to “specific species housing,” fearing that she might suffer a similar fate due to “inappropriate” conditions at the facility.

“It is high time we rethink animals in captivity, phase out zoos and focus our efforts on protecting our native species in the wild,” said Omar, the activist.

“Zoos are dark relics of the past. They must not be allowed to inflict pain and agony on any more animals. Karachi zoo should be restored to its original status as a botanical garden.”